Wednesday, 16 July 2014
Proof That Your Frame of Reference Has Shifted #4
You think nothing of giving rides to large groups of hitchhikers consisting entirely of strong young black men weilding machetes.
Proof That Your Frame of Reference Has Shifted #3
Whenever you drive past a Caucasian you don't recognize walking along the side of the road you immediately feel compelled to pull over to ask if they need help.
Thursday, 3 July 2014
Something More
I think that in our core, primitive reptile brain
we have a reflex that’s hard-wired in. It’s a reaction to the recognition of some
signs of disease when you see it, a recoiling from it, and I think evolution made
it flourish because it pulled us away from anything that might be contagious.
You feel it when you see certain
signs of illness, even when you may know intellectually that there is no risk
of transmission. For physicians, this reaction gets hammered down over time
like a nerve that’s goes dead. I don’t know what it’s like for other doctors,
but every now and then I can sometimes still get an initial flicker of it, if
only for an instant. Psychologists have
established a strong link between how symmetrical a person’s face is and how
attractive they are perceived to be. Conversely, over the years I’ve noticed
how a marked lack of symmetry in the
face, from disease or trauma, reliably provokes this reflex in most people,
sometimes even myself.
I felt that flicker the first time I saw Tom on the
ward. I don’t think he noticed, and I’m sure he had seen much worse. He had
come to hospital because it had become too painful to eat. Tom had a cancer on
the left of his face. It had wasted his body, disfigured his face, destroyed
the nerve that pulled his left eye to the side leaving nothing to oppose the
one pulling it to the center, and now the cancer had become infected. As awful
as this sounds, it’s far from unusual here on Tanna. We’d been getting a couple
of cases similar to Tom’s every month, many of them even much worse. Tom
actually looked fairly normal until you got up close.
At our hospital nurses do most of the admissions
and the physicians will review the patient on the ward later. The first
paragraph from the nurse pretty much told the whole story. Tom had a growth that
had slowly progressed over almost 2 years before he finally went to Vanuatu’s
capital on another island to seek medical attention. He obviously had had some
surgery because he had a scar at the site, but he couldn’t tell us much more
about anything else that happened there. The only other thing he remembered was
being told was that there was nothing more the doctors could do. Trying to get
any records from the capital is futile so we don’t bother any more.
We were very busy that day and I pretty much just
skimmed over the rest of the meager admitting documentation such as his social
history or family history. His situation was obvious and so were our treatment
options, both poor, so best to get on with doing what we can. We don’t have
much to offer terminally ill patients here. At home, this area of medicine is a
discipline unto itself, but in Vanuatu our offerings are pretty basic, mainly
trying to fix any complications of the illness that we can, such as secondary
infections. There’s nothing like prescribing Tylenol to fight cancer pain to
make you feel inadequate in your treatment plan.
Tom was with us for about a week or so. His
infection settled and he could eat small amounts of soft food. He said his pain
became controlled but no matter if he said it was good or bad, I never saw any
difference in his demeanor from day to day – stoic, but not in any angry,
defiant way. I’d probably describe it as…….calm.
Each day I saw him we talked for a just a couple of
minutes about how he was doing. These interactions were genuine but brief and
relatively unremarkable. This whole month has been very busy at the hospital so
between the time pressures and the language gap, I wouldn’t say I rushed, but I
didn’t linger. I can at least say that I did show him what I figure is always
the very minimum I can do - ask him, with my full attention, “How are you?”, and
mean it.
I was able to do some investigations for Tom. A
chest X-ray showed metastatic cancer lesions in his lungs. The ultrasound I did
showed the same in his liver, big ones. Tom was going to die. It would probably
be gradual, but it wouldn’t take too long now, especially once he could no
longer eat. Tom would do what all the terminally ill patients here do, go home
to their hut and be cared for by their family until the end.
The morning I discharged Tom was in the middle of a
very unusual 36 hour stretch for me at the hospital. There were quite a few
serious things to deal with, a couple of them just a bit too extreme to write
about here. Suffice it to say I was in a bit of an altered state by the end of
it, the kind where you know your brain needs a little time and distance before
it can process what just happened. On top of this was the impending visit to
the hospital that day from Vanuatu’s new Prime Minister. He was just elected a
few months ago and is the first leader the country has had who originates from
our island of Tanna. This is quite a big deal for people here as Tanna has a
bit of a reputation for being a backwater of Vanuatu, and for being full of what
they call Man Tanna, the Vanuatu
equivalent of redneck.
The hospital was buzzing with excitement and
activity. All the hospital staff were there, dressed up in their best clothes.
Flowers were hung from the ceilings and from trees around the grounds. Even the
road leading up to the hospital had been lined with flower petals on both
sides. It was quite pretty. I took special note of a few balloons hanging over
the front entrance. Consumer goods are pretty limited here and I had never seen
a balloon on Tanna before.
The visit was fairly brief and perfunctory. More of
a quick tour and a photo shoot than anything. The Prime Minister seemed nice
and I had a chance to meet him and his cabinet. I wanted terribly to ask him if
he could get the health ministry to finally pay me at least some of my
outstanding salary, but figured I’d better hold back. Still, it was hard not
get a little caught up in all the excitement.
The visit wound down after about half an hour. We
went out back behind the hospital to take a few group photos and then the Prime
Minister left with his entourage. Everyone was milling about, excitedly comparing
and exchanging the pictures they had taken. I was in the midst of figuring out
how to send a photo via Bluetooth when I happened to look up. A lone figure
walking quietly down the petal lined path away from the hospital caught my eye.
It might have been how calm he was amidst all the commotion, cutting through it
like a stone protruding from a river of running water, or maybe it was the four
brightly coloured balloons in his right hand. His back was to me and in front of him
stretched the falling coastline leading downhill to the beach and then the vast
ocean and horizon beyond. I knew it was Tom, and I knew that I was watching him
walking home to die.
My first thought was, “What could possibly make a
man in that situation take the time to acquire those balloons?” My second, of
how surreal this scene was - him walking away amidst all that excitement,
through the crowd and the decorations and the picturesque backdrop to it all.
My third was that I wanted to capture the image. I took out my camera but then
stopped. It didn’t seem right to take the picture without asking so I called
out his name. He stopped and smiled and came toward me. I asked if he was going
home and he said he was. I told him simply that I wanted to take his picture.
What he did next struck me at the time, but in the moment I didn’t know what to
make of it. He tidied his shirt, made his back ramrod straight and lifted his
head high and proud. It surprised me. I wouldn’t have expected a man under
those circumstances to do that. I took the photo.
As I went to say thank you and goodbye I felt
regret. I knew that there had been nothing wrong with my medical care for Tom.
It had been…...” fine”. No one would
have said I should have done anything different, but the unavoidable fact was
that I knew I could have given more,
and now I wished that I had. More what? I don’t know. Compassion? Time? I
really wasn’t sure, just something…….. more.
I tried to let him know by the way I shook his hand, putting my other on his
shoulder and saying as kindly as I could, “Good luck. You can come back if you
need to.” By his response, I’m pretty sure he understood what I was really
trying to say. We turned and parted ways, each of us going off in our own different
directions.
To be honest, ordinarily I would never write
something like this for so public a forum. It’s just a little more personal
than is entirely comfortable for me, and I always worry about the perception
that I’m trying to glamourize things. However, as I sat here tonight, having had
some time and distance to let the day’s events marinate, I think I came to
understand what happened when Tom got ready for that photo. I think he was
trying to say, “I’m still here. I don’t have to hide. I’m still human enough to
care about presenting myself the best that I can.” I also think that he truly wanted me to take that picture, thinking
that maybe, if he made it good enough, I might show it to others, and the more
people that saw it, the more powerful his statement would become. I’m still here. I don’t
have to hide. I’m still human. When
I realized this, I knew I
still had a last chance to do something more for him, and the idea wouldn’t
let me go until it was done. It would start with this:
The name on the front of the chart was Tom……..
Originally this essay ended with that photo I took of Tom; standing tall, balloons in hand. Showing it seemed like the whole point of the exercise. Ultimately though I felt that patient confidentiality prohibited me from publishing it, even if that patient lives in the middle bush of Tanna island and even if I know in my gut that he would have wanted it there. I removed the picture, though I desperately wanted to show it, and to as many people as possible. Hopefully after reading this you will also wish that it could have remained. While it's not the ending I envisioned, perhaps it's fitting that all of us are left wanting just a little something more.
Sean
Friday, 27 June 2014
Proof That Your Frame of Reference Has Shifted #2
Vanuatu woven basket, worn slung around the chest
by males and females for carrying small items ............... 500 vatu ($5)
Sarong......................................800 vatu
Sunscreen that would otherwise have been wasted,
absorbed by the leg hair you used to have, but now trim down...............10,000 vatu
Not caring that since you’ve come to Vanuatu you
at times trim your leg hair, wear a skirt and carry a purse.............................PRICELESS !
Sean
Sunday, 22 June 2014
A Queen Sacrifice
The queen is the most powerful
piece in a chess player’s arsenal. The queen is unique in that it can move in
any direction. It offers a great deal of protection and security and generally
makes solving your opponent more straightforward. Players covet the piece and
try to avoid losing it at all cost. Having ones queen taken by an opponent
usually puts them in both a tactical and perhaps more importantly,
psychological disadvantage.
A queen sacrifice is the term for a play in which the player purposely gives up his queen, expecting to win in return either multiple pieces from his opponent or a winning position. There is however, one celebrated instance in chess history where a chess master intentionally sacrificed his queen for neither of the usual rewards. He had always been renowned for his great creativity and resourcefulness, but on that day, playing one of the most important matches of his life, he could summon little of either. Then, for reasons no one at the time could fathom, he sacrificed his queen. He had realized what his game was lacking, and knew there was only one way to get it. It wasn't to be found in security. He had to be backed into a corner, he had to be pressured, pressured to create a solution when the most conventional means to do so were no longer an option and it worked. He won.
. . . . . . . . .
"What kind of stuff do you see?”. Prior to our departure from Victoria, it was a question that I asked many of my physician colleagues in the ViVa organization, all of whom had worked in Vanuatu before. Common responses included pneumonia, abscesses, tuberculosis, malnutrition, dysentery, burns and meningitis, not to mention all the obstetrical problems that arise. After listing most of the usual suspects they would usually pause and then try to somehow come up with a name for the other stuff. They were thinking of all the things you would never see in the west, wildly advanced cases of cancer or other diseases, weird manifestations of known illnesses, and stuff you just plain couldn't make up. You couldn’t because even though as a physician you might know the physiology of the problem, you could never have foreseen the effect that the swirl of forces on this island would bring.
Our hospital is about 100 m from our house, both of
which sit on the top of a hill. On the way there’s a beautiful view of a lush valley
nearby. “Time to put on the old suit and tie”, I often mumble as I don my
Hawaiian shirt, surf shorts and flip flops to make the trek to work. The
hospital itself is a square, one level complex with a central courtyard. It is
undeniably a bit run down, and generally speaking, very far from the brightness
and cleanliness we are used to in the first world. This can be a little arresting when you first
get here but fades with time as it quickly becomes apparent that you are not in
Kansas anymore. I think that many
westerners that come to Vanuatu and similar places often carry a bit of white
man’s guilt when they see the discrepancy between these living conditions and
their own. Eventually you just get over it. It’s not your fault. You don’t have
to be conciliatory or try to act like a Ni-Vanuatu. Respect their culture and
their country but be yourself.
Usually there are lots of locals milling about the
courtyard. They are mostly the family and friends of patients. Almost nobody
arrives for treatment at Lenakel hospital without a large entourage. There are
no designated visiting hours, partly because we rely on the families to do a
lot of the care for their sick relative, and I think partly because no one
would accept anything that restricted family contact any way. Sometimes it’s
been the middle of the night when I’ve been called in, and when I arrive the
whole hospital and courtyard were abuzz, filled with people, cell phone lights
waving. It’s like I walked in on a rave. Then, the whole place turns to look at
me and it’s time to be the dokta.
There are about forty beds in the hospital divided
among 2 adult wards, a children’s ward and a well-used maternity ward. There
are about 4-6 deliveries per day on average here, the vast majority done by our
extremely capable and experienced midwives. We even have a small operating room
and a labour and delivery room.
By now I know all the nurses so when I arrive on
the ward to do rounds there’s always some good chit chat that happens first. In
fact not much gets done around here without a chit chat and a laugh to go along
with it. It would just seem rude to do otherwise. People on Tanna take a lot of pride in this
attitude and I think for them it comes down to this: given the choice, why
would you do it any other way?
The Life Wisdom Of Gene Hackman
How do you convince someone to take precautions
against giving their infection to others when they don’t believe in germ theory?
How do you convince a parent to leave their child in hospital to treat their
meningitis when they believe it’s caused by spirits. How do you go about
persuading someone that the brutally aggressive kastom (traditional) massage they
got didn’t help them, and in fact was responsible for the ruptured bowel that
almost killed them? Similarly, the traditional practice of kastom cuts to the skin around a problem area do not let anything bad get out, but when covered by a dirty
medicinal leaf, are a great way to get an infection.
How do you get a husband to stop hitting his wife
and children when many males have traditionally seen this as part of their role
as a husband and father? How can I assess a potential psychiatric patient that
tells me they are a victim of spirits and curses, and that they feel insects
crawling all over them when in fact many of the island’s populace believe in
similar supernatural phenomenon and I pick ants off myself most of the time
when I’m in our kitchen. The list goes on. I don’t mean to sound dismissive of
these things. They are simply some of the realities here. In fact, frequently
brushing up against beliefs in magic and spirits has given me a new insight
into what life is like when it’s so influenced by such things. It’s really not
as big a mental leap as you might think, and there certainly are some great
things about it. It can be pretty comforting to believe that the spirits of
your ancestors roam the bush outside of your village and can be called on for
help. The world literally becomes a magical place.
Often it is the simple, mundane things about the
job that can be the most confounding. For example, nurses at the hospital, many
of whom are quite capable and do very good work, might not call you though when
a patient is critically ill because they must use their own cell phone to do so,
and no one wants to use up their credits. In general, nursing competence here can
vary widely. Some are great and some can be exasperating and bewildering in
what they do.
Most people don’t seem to know their age, or really
care for that matter. This somewhat indifferent attitude towards the passage of
time can also make it vexingly difficult take a history from a patient, or
determine when a problem actually began. Bislama, the main language here, is a
kind of pidgin English that initially developed to allow communication with the
English colonials. It doesn’t have an extensive vocabulary, just over 2000
words. While this makes it easier to learn, it doesn’t allow for a lot of
subtlety when describing something. Consequently, a patient will generally
describe a pain or a problem as either, ”bigwan (literally big one)”, or ,”smol
(small)” and nothing in between. You just have to roll with it, and above all,
phrase every question for a yes or no response.
The keeping of records in the country, medical or
otherwise, is generally quite poor, if they exist at all. A person could have
their name spelled differently at different times. Sometimes the father’s first
name is used as the patient’s last name and sometimes not. This can make
tracking charts and records a nightmare.
Patient privacy is practically nonexistent. You
might try to close the drapes around a patient’s bed to shut out the twenty
other people and family members in the room only to realize that a dozen others
are peering in through the windows, which of course, have no blinds.
People here have a very different attitude towards
illness and death. I guess when you see it up close a lot you accept it more as
a normal part of life. They are however;
by and large tremendously appreciative of whatever we do for them, even if
sometimes it’s really very little. A walk through the town usually draws at
least a couple of shouts of, “Hello Dokta!” followed by warm handshakes from
folks, often ones I haven’t even met before.
Beds of Nails
What do we have to work with to treat these
patients? Obviously, a heck of a lot less than we do at home. There is vastly
less equipment, available tests, medicines and just fewer options in general. There’s
no physiotherapy, no rehab, no social work, no mental health medicines or
programs. There is even less at the remote medical outposts that we pack up and
drive to on a weekly basis. In a way though, it’s cool to have to rely so much
on your clinical examination skills and judgement. The common algorithm is that
you formulate a list of potential diagnoses, and then you cross off all the
things you can’t test for, and then cross off all the things you can’t treat
for and see what’s left over. If there’s more than one, then treat for all of
them and hope for the best. Here, expectations of what can be done are very
realistic. No one expects you to know everything and be right all the time.
Generally, even if you don’t get it right people are better off than if you weren’t
here at all. The surprising thing was how liberating this situation can be. It
was like taking off that wetsuit that is a touch too small and then realizing
you weren’t breathing in fully all day, or that little hitch you never knew had
crept into your baseball swing, only feeling its absence when you were no
longer afraid of striking out.
Often something like abdominal pain, or shortness
of breath, symptoms that make a doctor consider numerous possibilities at home,
get treated repeatedly as one of a short list of things that we can actually do
something about. It always reminds me of an old saying: when all you have is a hammer everything starts looking like a nail.
Some days I feel like that’s all I have on the wards, beds and beds of nails.
. .
. . .
. .
Honestly, I can’t say I like that kind of pressure, but ultimately it is one of the main reasons that I came here. I knew what that
pressure would do. It would demand some things that I haven’t had to produce
working at home. There’s so much support there that it’s hard for that to
happen. It always makes me think of that famous chess match. I would have to
give up that support, give up my best tools, just as he sacrificed his queen,
in order to see if those things really are there to be given. I’d like to think
they are, even if ultimately I don’t want to have to use them every day of the week.
With two months left to go here it’s still too
early to claim success yet, but the endgame is looking good. My pieces are well
positioned, the chess board is a lot clearer, and when the game is over I hope
to be looking back without regret, at my queen sacrifice.
Sean
Monday, 19 May 2014
When We Were Kings
The Rumble in the Jungle.
If you are or were a boxing fan, and of my vintage, the phrase evokes deep reverence. It is regarded by many as being arguably the greatest sporting event of the 20th century. In October of 1974, George Foreman, the reigning heavyweight champion of the world faced Muhammad Ali in the jungles of Zaire. Ali had returmed to boxing after a 3 year ban for refusing to enter the draft for the Vietnam war, but had been consigned to fighting unworthy contenders after he lost his title bout with Joe Frazier in one of the most memorable bouts in the history of the sport. At 32 years old, his chances of regaining his crown seemed bleak.
Since I was a child, I have always loved Muhammad Ali. It always seemed a bit strange to me in a way because I usually idolized the strong, self-effacing, quietly dependable type when it came to sports. Ali was many things, but he was rarely quiet. He talked incesantly, and time and time again proclaimed himself, "The greatest of all time". I can't explain why, but I loved the guy.
George Foreman was 24 years of age and one of the most physically intimidating specimens to ever enter the game. His size, strength and sheer physical dominance was unlike anything seen before. After winning a gold medal at the 1968 Olympics he soon gained the heavyweight championship by demolishing the only two men to have ever beaten Ali, Joe Frazier and Ken Norton. Many in Ali's own camp secretly worried that he would actually be killed if he fought Foreman.
The two men agreed to fight if a five million dollar purse was guaranteed. The president of Zaire was eager for the international publicity the event would bring and agreed to put up most of the money. For those of a younger vintage it may be hard to conceive of a time before MMA when boxing.... mattered. A heavyweight title bout commanded the attention of the entire world and this one, above all, had the world on the edge of its seat. The story is told in the Oscar winning 1996 documentary, "When We Were Kings", one of my most beloved films of all time.
During the months he spent in Zaire training before the fight Ali was a master at public relations, even more so than usual. Some close to him have suggested that he did it just as much to calm his own fears as anything else. Whatever the reason, the country of Zaire loved him. Wherever he went people chanted the iconic phrase. " Ali boma ye, Ali boma ye!" which translates to "Ali, kill him!"
My favourite footage in the docummentary shows Ali, just days before the fight, out for a training run on a dusty Zaire backroad. The sun is setting. He sets a relaxed pace in his grey sweats, and as he runs men and boys start to run alongside him, joy and excitement bursting from their faces. "Ali boma ye, Ali boma ye!"
His charisma carries them along behind him like a jetstream. Then he stops and does what he did best. He floats. He shadow boxes and he trash talks. For me, it's pure magic.
Today I was not feeling magical. I had been called to the hospital a few times during the night and was tired. Still I'd been feeling a little guilty lately for not getting much exercise. Things have been very busy on the wards and it has taken its toll. Since being on Tanna I have managed to occassionally get some cardiovascular exercise, despite the heat. Most often it's near the end of the day in the small window between when it starts to cool down and when the mosquitoes come out. Our house sits near the hospital on top of the highest hill in town and I will sometimes do sprints up the hill. I find it works well. Because of the high intensity I don't have to do it for very long so by the time I'm overheated I'm already finished. Today I didn't plan on running the hill very hard and was just proud of myself for even gettting out the door.
It's rare to see runners here, especially white ones (or in my case, white-ish) so I usually draw a lot of attention. Most people here do so much physical work as a part of their everyday life that the concept of intentional exercise is somewhat foreign. I'll admit to feeling a little sheepish the one time when I was running the hill and a guy, who was probably older than me, stepped out of the bush carrying three large sections of a tree trunk on his jungle hardened shoulder. He gave me a quizzical look and then proceeded to carry them up the hill.
I started off easy, and as I would walk back down the hill for the next run up I noticed I was attracting the attention of a few kids. They were boys around eight to 13 years old and they were staring at me with a mixture of fascination and bemusement. At the very least though, they were clearly intrigued. After I had walked by them a few more times I used what little Bislama I have to invite them to join in. We lined up and raced. They whooped and laughed out of pure fun and some surprise I imagine as I beat them up the hill. That was it. The game was now ON.
They got smart though. Half the group would sit out one race while I continued and then jump up to go the next time. My place finishes steadily plummeted from there. Eventually I told them I had one more left in me because I was, as they say in Bislama, "half-dead". I looked up the hill to see one of the previous race's contestants splayed out like a star fish at the top of the hill gasping for air. They keeled over laughing when I pronounced him, "full-up dead!".
I lost the last race badly, but you never saw a loser with a bigger smile. I high fived a few good-byes and started to slowly jog up the dusty road to the house. It was beautiful out. Near the top of our hill you get a view out over the ocean. The waves were breaking and the sun was setting. I was lost in the view when the boys slowly came up from behind to run with me. They had figured out that I was the doctor and I think they found it quite a hoot that someone in that position would goof around with them. There was definitely a little bit of "star power" going on.
With the kids, the dusty road, the warm glow of the setting sun, I couldn't help but think of the footage from my favourite documentary. I used to box a long time ago and the sport is popular on Tanna so I asked them If they knew how. As we ran along they showed me their best jabs and crosses and I showed them mine. It only lasted for a few precious kilometers, but for those brief, transcendent minutes........we were kings. It was pure magic.
Sean
Afterword:
Ali won the Rumble in the Jungle with a epic knockout in the eighth round. After goading Foreman to tire himself out with wild punches while Ali conserved energy laying on the ropes, the famous "rope-a-dope" tactic, Ali pounced with a flurry of near poetic combinations that sent Foreman to the canvas.
Some of the original footage of Ali running in Zaire can be found at :
www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-Jom8Ok_DA
Monday, 5 May 2014
Proof That Your Frame of Reference Has Shifted #1
When your eight year old daughter bursts into the house and says,"Dad where's the machete?", and you reply disinterestedly, "By the front door", without a second thought or even looking up from your book.
Sean
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)